Kya Talaq e salasa ke Maslah me IJMA huwa…??

Muqallid Hazrat kehte hain 3 Talaq kehne pe 3 Talaq shumar hone pe Ijma hy. ye jhoot hy JO unka Masla ka Daleel Quran aur sahii hadees se sabit hi nahi hy to Ijma kaisa hota…??????? Aek baat yaad rakhiye Jo bhi Ijma Sabit hona chahiye. Balke Sahaba me is Maslah me IJMA Nahi huwa Balke Ikhtilaf huwa Lekin Raaze Qaul 1 Talaq Shumar Hoga Quran sahii hadees Roshni me Aur Sahaba ke Aqwal se..

Point Number 1

Pehli baat Ijma Huwa Ya Nahi karke Muhadaseen ka kya Raay dekhiye

1 Imam Nawawi Kehte hy Is Masle me Ijma Nahi balke Ikhtilaf hy Aur A lake Bayan karte hy ke “Tawus (r) and Ahle-Zahir, Muhammad bin Ishaq, Muhammad bin Maqatal and Hajjaj bin Irtiqa inme Ikhtilaf tha ” [ Sharh Muslim Al-Nawawi, Baab Al-Talaq ]

2 Imam Ibn Rashd Qurtubi Maulud (560-595 H) a Maliki Jurist Kehte hy Iss Masle me Ulama me Ikhtilaf hy 3 talaq Ekhatti dene pe 3 talaq hoga ya nahi Baaz Ulama kehte hain 1 hi talaq Shumar hoga [ Bidayat Al-Mujtahid Waghasyat Al-Maqtasid 2/61-63 ]

3.Imam Talmasani Ibrahim bin Yahya Maliki (633 H) :

Allama Qastalani Sharh of Sahih Bukhari Kehte hy

Imam Talmasani Ibrahim bin Yahya bin Musa Abu Ishaq Kehte hy Hamari Maliki Madhab me Fatwa Maujood hy ke Aek Majlees me 3 Talaq 1 Hi Shumar hoga { Irshad Al-Sari 8/127 }

4 Imam Abu-Abdullah Muhammad Qurtubi 672 H:

Imam Abu-Abdullah Us Saal me Wafat huwe Jo Imam Nawawi ne wafat huwe.

@Imam Abu-Abdullah Muhammad Qurtubi Ne Bhi Wahi Kaha jo Imam Nawawi ne kahi… ImaM Abu-Abdullah ne bhi Yahi kahi ke Ijma nahi Balke Salaf me Ikhtilaf hain.

5 Imam Abu-Abdullah Muhammad Qurtubi Kehte hy Hamare Ulama(yani Maliki Jurist) Kehte hy 1 Majlees mein 3 Talaq ka malsa pe Ima-e-Fatwa ( Maliki Jurists) IJMA hy… Aur Jumhoor salaf ka Ahi Madhab hy Tawus aur Baaz Ahle-Zawahir Bhi 3 talaq 1 hi shumar hoga … Aur bhi Muhammad bin Ishaq and Hajjaj bin Irtiqa Rivayat hy ke Talaqe shumar nahi hote ,, Maqtal ka bhi A hi Madhab hy… Hajjaj se Rivayat hy kehte hy Jumhoor salaf aur Ima-e-Fatwa isse Qayal the..{Tafsir Qurtubi 3/219 }

-Imam Abu-Abdullah Muhammad Qurtubi kehte is Masle me Ikhtilaf hy kitne Talaq huwa karke .. Sahabe me se Hazrat Ali, Ibn-e-Masud, Ibn-e-Abbas, Zubair bin Awam, Abdur-Rehman bin Awf (R.a) A sab 3 Talaq 1 hona ka Kayal the….[ Tafsir e Qurtubi 3/132 ]

6.Imam Shukwani (rah) Kehte hain Agar aek Mujtahid bhi Ikhtilaf kiya to Madhab-A- Jumhoor Ahle Ilm Nazdeek IJMA Nahi hota aur Hujjat bhi nahi hota…. aur Imam Surfi kehte hy Aek Mujtahid sare Mujtahid log ka khilaf ho to IJMA Nahi hota jab tak wo Mujtahid ruzu nahi kare…..

aur aek wazahat karke likte hain : Kabi kabi 1 Mujtahid bhi sare Mujthid se khilaf bhi Haqq banta hy { Irshad Al-Mafhul 88-89 ]

7 Aur aek jagah me likha hy Agar Aek Maslah me 1 ya 2 Ahle Ilm Ikhtilaf kiya to wuse IJMA Nahi kehte Balke Ikhtilaf kehte hy Ahi Madhhab Jamhur Ahle-Ilm Nazdeek.

[ See Al-Ihkam Al-Ibn e Hazm 1/213, Muslim Al-Subut 2/222 ]

Ye sare Muhadaseen se A Pata chalta hy ke A Masle me Sahaba me IJMA Nahi Balke IkHtilaf hy…Baaz Log IJMA IJMA Bolka awam ko bewakoof banate hy wo log jhoote hain…

8 Imam shafai (r.a) ne farmate hy : Musalmano ke ijma se ye wazih hai ke jab koi Muslim nabi s.a.w ki sahii hadees paye toh uske liye sakt Haram hy usse phirey ya koi rai qayem kare

[ Tazeem Al-Sunnah 28, Alam Al-Muaqain 2/282 ]

Muhaddaseen aur Ulama

Niche Diya GAYA Huwa Muhadaseen aur Ulama ka ahi raay hain ke Aek Majlees 3 talaq 1 Hi Maana jata hain.

1. Allahmah Aini kehte hain :Maddhab- A- Tawus,

Muhammad bin Ishaq,

Al Hajjaj,

Ibrahim Nakhi,

Ibn Maqatal and

Ahlul dahirr A sab is masla ke kayal the Ekhatti 3 talaq diye to wo 1 talaq hi shumar hoga [Umdatul Qadri (20/223)]

2. Imam Ahmed Bin Hambal AHi Raay tha…. Ibe tayymiyah kehte hy Imam Ahmed bin hambal Aapna Raay ko phir Ruzu karliya hy 3 talaq 1 hi shumar hoga {[Fatawa Ibn Taymiyyah}

3. Imam Ibn Rashd Qurtubi a Maliki Jurist Kehte hy baaz Ulama kehte hy 3 talaq ekatti diyajaiye 3 shumar hoga aur Baaz Ulama kehte hy 3 talaq Ekhatti diyajaye 1 hi shumar hoga…. Allahu Alam

[ Bidayat Al-Mujtahid Waghasyat Al-Maqtasid 2/61-63]

4. Fakhr ud din al-Razi Is Ayat 2:229 ke Niche kehte hy Bahut sare Ulama A hi Kayal the Agar koyi shaks 2 ya 3 talaq diya to 1 hi talaq shumar hoga
: وهو اختيار كثير من علماء الدين، أنه لو طلقها اثنين أو ثلاثاً لا يقع إلا الواحدة، وهذا القول هو الأقيس، لأن النهي يدل على اشتمال المنهي عنه على مفسدة راجحة، والقول بالوقوع سعى في إدخال تلك المفسدة في الوجود وأنه غير جائز، فوجب أن يحكم بعدم الوقوع.

5. Imam Abu Hiyan al Andalusi kehte hy Agar Agar koyi shaks 2 ya 3 talaq diya to 1 hi talaq shumar hoga [in his Commentary of Quran under ayah 229 of Surah Al- Baqrah]

6. SHAEIKL- ISLAM IBN TAYMIYYA: TALAQ BIDAYI WAQE NAHI HOTI (AL-FATAWA 5/32)

7. IBN QAYYIM: ISI KE QAAYIL HAI. (ZAADUL MAAD 5/218-238)

8. IBN HAZAM: ISI K QAAYIL HAI. (AL-MUHALLA 9/358, AUR ALMAALATA 1945)

9. ALLAMA SHOKANI: ISI KO TARJEEH DETE HAIN: (NEELIL AWTAAR 4/319)

@ TALAQ BIDAYI KA HUKM NA ALLAH TALA NE DIYA HAI AUR NA HI RASUL SAW NE LEHAZA YE MARDUD HAI TO PHIR ISKA SHUMAR KYUN KAR HO SAKTA HAI.

10. Shiek Bin Baaz ka bhi A hi Fatwa hy {Fataawa Islamiyyah, 3/281, 282.}

11. Al Allamah Albany Sahab ka bhi yahi Raay(Opinion) Hain. [Irwa al Ghulayl vol 7 page 145 hadith no: 2063]

Aakhri Baat :

ye Haqeeqat hy ke Iss Masle mein Ulama me Ikhtilaf hy lekin Raaze Qaul Ekhatti 3 talaq 1 hi shumar hoga Quran aur sahii hadees ke roshni me .. Jab Ulama me Ikhtilaf huwa to Allah Humko Quran me Hukum deta hy Jab Ulama me Ikhtilaf huwa to us Maslah Allah aur Rasool ke taraf phirawo{ Quran 4;59}

Wallahu Alam.

Romanised By : Abdul Qadeer Salafi.

Talaq e Salasa ke bareme Tafseel ke liye Ye Post dekhiye :

Link : https://thewayofsalafiyyah.wordpress.com/2017/01/30/talaq-e-salasa-quran-aur-saheeh-hadees-ki-roshni-mein/